top of page

The American Civil War. What the Experts Actually Say

Writer: Sam Morgan
Sam Morgan
Jul 27
2 min read

The phrase "second civil war" has become a fixture of American political conversation, fueled by polarization, viral warnings, and no shortage of alarmist headlines. But when researchers who actually study civil conflict for a living are asked the question directly, their answer is far more measured than the discourse around it suggests.



The scholarly bar is high — and the U.S. doesn't meet it. Academic definitions of civil war typically require a state-based conflict between a government and an organized armed opposition, usually crossing a threshold of roughly 1,000 battlefield deaths. The Center for Strategic and International Studies has stated plainly that the risk of an actual U.S. civil war is negligible, arguing that recent tragic events, however serious, don't reflect the organized, territorial nature of true civil conflict. Prediction markets echo this: contracts on a U.S. civil war occurring before the end of 2026 have traded around just 8% — priced as a tail risk, not a genuine expectation, reflecting the reality that civil wars require organized armed factions and territorial control that simply don't exist in the U.S. today.


The real concern lies elsewhere. Nearly every serious analysis converges on the same point: the greater danger isn't organized civil war, but a rise in fragmented, socially amplified political violence — lone individuals or small groups acting out of escalating polarization rather than coordinated militias seeking to seize territory. Surveys have found a troubling increase in the share of Americans who believe civil conflict is likely, or even necessary, alongside greater willingness among some respondents to endorse political violence outright. That shift in public sentiment doesn't cause a war, but it does raise the odds of isolated attacks and small-scale unrest.


Data backs this up. Princeton's Bridging Divides Initiative reported that political violence in the U.S. escalated notably in 2025 and has continued rising into 2026, including high-profile assassinations, threats against public officials, and volatile federal operations — a trend researchers describe as a genuine escalation in risk, even without approaching anything resembling war.


A useful framework comes from political scientist Barbara Walter, who has studied civil conflicts from Northern Ireland to Syria. Walter identifies two key predictors of instability: "anocracy," meaning a partial or weakened democracy rather than a fully consolidated one, and the presence of identity-based political parties. She has argued that both warning signs have become more visible in the U.S. over the past decade, tied to a longer-term erosion of democratic institutions — a caution about direction and trend, not an imminent forecast.


The bottom line experts converge on is a nuanced one: a full-scale civil war remains highly unlikely given the federal government's continued institutional and military capacity. But rising political violence, deepening polarization, and weakening democratic norms are real and measurable trends — conditions serious enough to watch closely, even if they fall well short of the civil war label so often attached to them.

Comments


bottom of page